VOTES FOR WOMEN
When the Suffragettes Came to the Scottish Borders
From a Hawick campaign shop to the Kelso racecourse case and a Jedburgh trial, follow the Borders struggle for women’s votes and the human cost of protest.
Imagine walking through Hawick during an election campaign in 1909. There are political notices to read, arguments to overhear and the usual business of a busy manufacturing town carrying on around them. Then a shop window stops you. The campaign being advertised is about Parliament, but the women organising it cannot vote in the election they are trying to influence.
This is no invented setting. A surviving photographic postcard shows a Women’s Social and Political Union shop in Hawick during the February 1909 by-election campaign. Four campaigners stand outside. Notices occupy the window. One advertises a meeting involving Emmeline Pethick-Lawrence. The photograph catches the suffrage movement doing something practical and recognisably modern: taking premises, making itself visible and bringing a national argument into the street.
Four years later, another part of that argument would reach a Borders courtroom. An attempted fire at Kelso Racecourse brought suffragettes before the sheriff and jury at Jedburgh. The consequences extended far beyond the region, into hunger strikes, temporary releases, arrests and the forcible feeding of Arabella Scott.
Between the campaign shop and the criminal case lies a story about a country deciding who counted as a political adult. The Borders were part of that struggle, through ordinary streets, public meetings and extraordinary acts of confrontation.
A town full of work, with a restricted political voice
Hawick was a place where women’s labour was impossible to overlook. Its textile economy depended on skills, wages and households in which paid and unpaid work overlapped. The women who kept the Borders mills running were contributing to a prosperous industry while living within a political system that excluded their sex from the parliamentary franchise.
That contradiction gave the suffrage argument force. Women paid taxes, obeyed laws, raised families and earned money. Why should a parliamentary vote be treated as something beyond them? The question could be posed in a factory town just as sharply as in an Edinburgh drawing room. It concerned legislation about work, education, health and the conditions in which households survived.
We should not assume that every working woman supported the same organisation, or even supported votes for women. Communities were divided by politics, religion, class and personal conviction. A woman could favour the vote and reject militancy, or agree with a particular protest while distrusting the movement behind it. The point of a local story is to recover those possibilities, rather than turn the whole town into a single cheering crowd.
Nor was every adult man already enfranchised. Before 1918, parliamentary voting still involved restrictions which excluded many men. The suffrage campaign took place within a wider argument about representation, but the complete exclusion of women from parliamentary voting was a distinct barrier. A woman’s qualifications could not overcome it simply by becoming more respectable, more educated or more industrious.
Suffragists and suffragettes were not interchangeable
The vocabulary matters because it reveals different ideas about how change could be won. Suffragists pursued constitutional methods: organising, lobbying, petitioning and trying to persuade Parliament. Suffragettes became associated with a more confrontational wing of the movement, particularly the Women’s Social and Political Union, or WSPU.
The distinction was not between women who cared and women who did not. Constitutional campaigning demanded persistence, money, public courage and immense organisational labour. Nor did joining a militant organisation mean that every member committed a criminal act. Selling newspapers, speaking at meetings and running a campaign shop were essential parts of the same machinery that made dramatic protest possible.
There were also organisations beyond a simple two-sided picture. Arabella Scott’s involvement with the Women’s Freedom League before her later WSPU activity shows that campaigners could move between groups and change their views about tactics. Political commitment was a journey, not a label attached permanently at birth.
It is easy to let the most spectacular events dominate everything around them. A smashed window or an attempted fire attracts a headline. An evening spent folding leaflets does not. Yet neither form of activity makes much sense without the others: the movement needed audiences, networks, places to meet and people willing to keep returning after disappointment. The Hawick photograph is valuable because it restores that everyday work to the story.
The shop window in Hawick
The London Museum’s postcard identifies the four women outside the Hawick shop as Theresa Garnett, Nellie Crocker, Gladys Roberts and Edith New. It dates the scene to the WSPU’s February 1909 by-election campaign. These names allow us to see organisers rather than a generic group of women in old-fashioned clothes.
The window notice mentioning Emmeline Pethick-Lawrence also reveals a strategy. The organisation wanted people to come to a meeting and hear an argument directed at the political leadership of the day. It was selling attention as well as a cause. A shop could act as a meeting point, display board and public declaration that the campaign had arrived.
Consider the labour implied by those arrangements. Premises had to be obtained, material brought in, notices displayed and information passed to potential supporters. Someone had to answer questions from passers-by who might be curious, sympathetic or hostile. Those practical requirements are deductions from what a campaign shop did, not a claim that the camera recorded every conversation outside this particular door.
The photograph gives the Borders a place in the movement’s visual history. Instead of picturing suffrage only through Westminster demonstrations, we can imagine the argument at pavement level in Hawick. Its strength is its ordinariness. A familiar kind of town building had become a temporary outpost in a campaign to alter the relationship between half the population and the state.
Why a by-election drew campaigners north
An election concentrated attention. Candidates, newspapers, meetings and political loyalties converged on a constituency for a short period. For campaigners excluded from the parliamentary ballot, that concentration offered another way to exert pressure: influence the people who could vote, challenge candidates and make the treatment of women part of the contest.
A by-election could therefore become much larger than its local result. The governing party might be confronted over national policy in a place far from Parliament. Questions that seemed abstract in a speech acquired an immediate edge when asked in a crowded meeting or displayed in a shop window.
The existence of the Hawick shop does not prove that the WSPU controlled local opinion or determined the outcome. It proves organised intervention. That is significant enough. Campaigners were treating the Border constituency as a place where political pressure could be applied, rather than as a remote audience waiting to hear what London decided.
For local people, the visit also brought choices. Attend a meeting, buy a paper, argue at the door, ignore it, join in. History often presents political movements as if everyone encountered them through a manifesto. More commonly, people met them through a friend, an interruption, a striking notice or an argument that made the day’s journey home feel different. The shop photograph lets us glimpse the point at which a national demand entered those personal routines.
A movement carried along roads and railways
The campaign depended on movement. Speakers travelled, organisers shifted between constituencies, papers circulated and news of arrests arrived from elsewhere. The Borders’ towns were connected to a national political world through transport and print, as well as through the people who left home to work or study.
That network is easier to understand alongside the railway that changed the Borders. Trains did more than move goods and holidaymakers. They helped ideas travel, brought visiting speakers within reach and allowed local arguments to become part of wider campaigns. A station was one of the places where distant politics could step down onto a familiar platform.
The surviving evidence also resists a narrow definition of “local”. An event in Hawick could involve campaigners who had come from elsewhere. An action at Kelso could lead to imprisonment in Edinburgh and Perth. A family in the Borders might read about those consequences in the same newspaper that carried market prices and local notices.
This mobility does not make the story less Borders history. It explains how Borders history worked. The region was never sealed off from national change. Its streets, institutions and people were connected to systems larger than the map of a single town. Suffrage campaigning used those connections deliberately, turning travel, publicity and organisation into political tools.
Kelso: when protest became a criminal case
By 1913, militant tactics had become more confrontational. In the Borders, the attempted burning of a stand at Kelso Racecourse brought the struggle into the criminal courts. Arabella Charlotte Scott, Edith Hudson, Elizabeth Thomson and Agnes Colquhoun Thomson appear in the National Records of Scotland’s file for the case.
The surviving catalogue is precise about the outcome for three of them. At Jedburgh Sheriff Jury Court on 19 May 1913, Scott and Hudson were convicted of attempted fire-raising and each sentenced to nine months’ imprisonment. Elizabeth Thomson was convicted and sentenced to three months. Agnes is recorded as having been tried on the charges; the catalogue wording does not support simply announcing that all four received the same conviction and sentence.
That precision changes the telling. It prevents a dramatic group story from flattening separate legal outcomes into one. It also keeps the event what it was: an attempted fire-raising case, not evidence that the racecourse was destroyed. The difference matters to the history of the place and to the people involved.
The choice of a sporting venue widened the confrontation beyond a political meeting. Property, public safety and the disruption of ordinary activities became part of the argument. Supporting women’s parliamentary rights did not require approving every militant tactic. Equally, disapproval of the offence does not explain away the political exclusion which the campaigners were trying to end.
Arabella Scott was more than a name in a charge
Arabella Scott was born in Dunoon in 1886, studied at the University of Edinburgh and became a teacher. She and her sister Muriel were active in the suffrage cause. Her education and employment make the political contradiction particularly clear: a woman could teach and take part in public argument while remaining excluded from parliamentary voting.
Her earlier campaigning included an attempt to deliver a petition to the Prime Minister in London in 1909, followed by imprisonment for obstruction. This was not someone whose political life began with the Kelso incident. The later case emerged from years of commitment and a developing belief in more militant methods.
It would be misleading to present her as speaking for every woman in the Borders. She was a campaigner whose actions brought her into the region’s history, and whose subsequent treatment connected a Borders court case to national debates. Her individual experience can illuminate those connections without becoming a substitute for the many quieter participants whose names are less easily recovered.
Teaching also supplies a useful perspective on the suffrage demand. Political rights were not a prize for an exceptional woman’s achievement, to be awarded only after she proved herself unusually able. The campaign challenged a sex-based exclusion. Scott’s qualifications demonstrate the contradiction, but the principle reached beyond university graduates to women with very different lives, incomes and opportunities.
Hunger strike and the revolving prison door
After the 1913 conviction, Scott was sent to Calton Gaol in Edinburgh and went on hunger strike. The authorities faced a prisoner prepared to endanger her health rather than submit quietly to the sentence. The government’s response included temporary release under the Prisoners (Temporary Discharge for Ill-Health) Act 1913, widely called the Cat and Mouse Act.
The mechanism allowed a weakened prisoner to be released, then required her return to continue the sentence. In practice, it created a continuing contest over recovery, surveillance and re-arrest. A release did not mean that the political argument or the prison sentence had ended. Scott was repeatedly detained and released before being taken to Perth in 1914.
For supporters, this cycle exposed the coercive power of the state against women campaigning for representation. For officials, it created a problem of enforcement which could not be resolved merely by writing down the term of imprisonment. The prisoner’s refusal of food made her physical condition inseparable from political calculation.
The process also depended on a network beyond the cell. A released prisoner needed somewhere to recover and people who could help. Families worried, supporters organised and officials exchanged reports. The drama was not confined to a confrontation between one brave individual and an abstract government. It involved institutions, relatives, campaigners and staff caught within a policy whose human consequences kept escaping its administrative language.
Perth: the body becomes the battleground
Scotland’s People’s account, based on prison records, documents Scott’s force-feeding at Perth between June and July 1914. The dates and surviving medical reports make it impossible to treat her suffering as a decorative detail in a colourful campaigning story. This was a serious bodily intervention carried out in the course of enforcing a political prisoner’s sentence.
The language of official records can feel distant. It sorts days into entries, treatment into procedure and people into administrative responsibilities. Read against the knowledge that a conscious person was resisting, the apparent calm becomes unsettling. Historical understanding requires us to recognise both the documentation and the violence it records.
The consequences travelled beyond Perth. Correspondence preserved by the National Library of Scotland includes campaigners’ enquiries and protests about the treatment of suffrage prisoners, including Scott. Her case was being watched and argued over by people outside the prison. Letters turned a closed institution into a matter of public concern.
That wider attention is part of the story’s power. An attempted offence at Kelso and a conviction at Jedburgh had led into an argument about what the state could do to a woman’s body. The distance between the Borders and the prison did not break the connection. It showed how a local event could expose the harshest edge of a national political conflict.
The quiet campaign still mattered
Militant suffering is difficult to look away from, and it deserves attention. It should not erase the constitutional campaign running alongside it. Petitions, public meetings, societies and personal persuasion created political pressure across decades. Those methods were often less photogenic and less dramatic, but they involved sustained effort rather than passive waiting.
A person might organise a meeting after a day’s work, distribute information through friends or argue patiently with a relative who believed women should stay out of politics. These are representative possibilities, not reconstructed biographies of unnamed Borders campaigners. They help us see the kinds of labour which a successful movement required and which a criminal file is unlikely to record.
The history of Peter Scott’s Hawick mill and the wider industrial archive supply the setting in which such arguments would have been understood. Wages, hours and household security were not separate from politics. A vote was one means of influencing the laws which shaped those conditions.
The movement also had to confront disagreement within itself. Tactics could attract attention and alienate possible supporters at the same time. Leaders made choices which others rejected. A good history can acknowledge that conflict without making the campaign seem incoherent. Large changes are usually made by people who agree about a destination more readily than they agree about every step towards it.
1918 was a victory with a boundary around it
The Representation of the People Act received Royal Assent on 6 February 1918. It enfranchised women aged over thirty who met the relevant property or related qualifications, while greatly expanding male voting rights. This was a historic break with women’s complete exclusion from parliamentary elections, but it was not equal suffrage.
Women under thirty remained outside the parliamentary electorate even if they had worked, campaigned or contributed to the war effort. Older women did not all qualify automatically. The age and qualification rules created a boundary inside the victory, separating those able to vote from those still waiting.
It is tempting to explain the change as a simple reward for women’s wartime service. The war mattered, but the result also followed decades of organised pressure and a wider reform of the electorate. The long campaign should not vanish behind a story in which rights were generously bestowed after women proved useful during an emergency.
Equal parliamentary voting terms came in 1928, when the voting age for women was brought into line with that for men at twenty-one. For a young woman who had watched the pre-war campaign, the interval could encompass years of adult work and responsibility. The vote arrived by stages, and the distinction between those stages is central to understanding what campaigners had won.
Look again at the shop photograph
Return to the Hawick postcard. The campaigners are standing outside a shop, in a place which could easily be passed without a thought. Knowing what followed gives the scene weight, but it should not make us treat it merely as a prelude to attempted fires and prison cells. It records an important political act in its own right: women claiming space in the public life of a town.
Mark’s film on the Gala Aisle inscription offers an unexpected parallel in the way we read surviving evidence. A few words, a name or an image can open a much larger history when we stop to examine it. Here the source is a campaign photograph rather than carved stone. The method is the same: begin with what actually survives, then follow the connections carefully.
Hawick, Kelso and Jedburgh form three points in this Borders story: organisation, confrontation and judgement. Beyond them lie Edinburgh, Perth and Westminster, joined by campaigners, trains, letters and laws. The region was part of the struggle throughout, not a quiet margin on which national events occasionally cast a shadow.
The next time an election notice appears in a window, it is worth remembering the women who used a Hawick shop to influence an election in which they had no parliamentary vote. Their presence makes an ordinary street a place of democratic history. The right now exercised in a few private moments at a ballot box was once an argument conducted very publicly indeed.

Your memories and comments
Do you remember this place, or have something to add? Share a memory, ask a question or help us fill in the story.
Loading comments…