Prisons and local justice
Forgotten Prisons and Lock-ups of the Scottish Borders
From Jedburgh’s castle jail to Selkirk’s former prison library, uncover the cells, records and changing ideas of justice hidden in familiar Borders towns.
Imagine hearing the town carry on without you. A cart on the street. Voices outside. A bell marking an hour that seems to have taken far longer to arrive indoors. The building may be at the centre of the community, yet a locked door has placed you a world away from it.
The forgotten prisons of the Scottish Borders were not all remote fortresses. Some occupied civic buildings through which townspeople passed on ordinary business. Some stood beside a church or beneath rooms where authority met. Some were purpose-built, with plans intended to improve the prisoner as well as contain them.
Their remains are still among us. Jedburgh's castle-like jail is the most obvious. In Selkirk, a former prison became a place for books. Lauder's town hall preserves another chapter. At Greenlaw the relationship between church tower and confinement can stop you in your tracks.
Together they reveal a history less simple than a procession from cruelty to kindness. Improvements brought cleaner plans and different routines; they also brought new ways of separating and controlling people. And behind every discussion of walls, inspectors and regulations were individuals trying to get through the day until the door opened again.
The town's business under one roof
A tolbooth was more than a prison. In Scottish burgh life it could bring together the collection of dues, council business, the court and custody. That mixture explains why the history of confinement is so closely woven into the history of town centres.
The arrangement had an unsettling intimacy. A place of public administration could contain people whose freedom that administration had removed. Authority did not need a separate campus on the edge of town; it could work above a busy street, within sight of the market.
Our story of trade from the market cross onwards explores another part of that civic world. Markets needed rules, weights, dues and people to enforce them. The same streets that offered opportunity could deliver a summons or a sentence.
We should not imagine one standard tolbooth plan applied across the region. Buildings were altered, rebuilt and adapted. A room might acquire a new function without the exterior changing enough to announce it to a later visitor.
That is why an old town hall deserves a second look. The grand stair, bell or clock may be the feature we notice first. The less conspicuous question is where a prisoner entered, where they waited, and how close confinement stood to the public life above and around it.
Lauder's clock kept time for prisoners
Lauder's town hall stands prominently in Mid Row. Its present form owes much to an eighteenth-century rebuilding, but the history of a town hall or tolbooth reaches back at least into the sixteenth century. The lower floor once served as a prison.
The building's handsome civic presence can disguise that practical purpose. A clock and a meeting room tell the town that it is governed. A locked room downstairs gives the same statement a different weight.
Historic Environment Scotland records that prison use ended in 1843, after a government inspector condemned it. That short fact contains a turning point. Accommodation accepted by a community could become unacceptable when measured against an outside standard.
Another record adds a surprising neighbour to the picture. In 1771 a proposed new school was justified because Lauder had only a vault below its tolbooth for schooling, without a fireplace. The architectural drawing survives in the National Records of Scotland. It reminds us how many essential activities might compete for inadequate civic space.
The point is not that schoolchildren and prisoners necessarily occupied one room together. The evidence concerns a multipurpose building and the demand for something better. A town could be proud of its public institutions while housing them in conditions that later generations would struggle to imagine.
At Lauder, the movement from familiar local provision to inspection and condemnation is visible within a building that still anchors the street.
A prison mistaken for a church tower
Greenlaw offers one of the Borders' most striking combinations of uses. The historic church complex includes a tower associated with the old jail. If you arrive expecting every building to advertise its original purpose, the arrangement is disconcerting.
The tower belongs to the story of a county town whose civic responsibilities included confinement. It is a reminder that the familiar outlines of a Scottish settlement can contain several histories at once. A feature read at first as purely ecclesiastical may also speak about civil authority.
The town later acquired a separate jail. A nineteenth-century gazetteer describes the new prison, built in 1824, with eighteen cells, day rooms and courts for exercise, enclosed by a high wall. Even then, the writer anticipated alterations to accommodate the new separate system.
That is an extraordinary detail. A building could be relatively new and already require change because the theory of imprisonment had moved on. The problem was no longer only whether the walls were secure. It was how the prisoners should live within them.
Greenlaw also warns the researcher about a trap of names. The Greenlaw associated with French prisoners of war near Penicuik is a different place. A shared place-name can send a dramatic history to the wrong town if nobody stops to check.
Here, the local story is strong enough on its own: tower, county responsibilities, new jail and changing expectations of discipline.
Jedburgh's castle that was really a jail
At the top of Castlegate, Jedburgh Castle Jail makes a deliberate impression. Battlements and towers give the place a fortified appearance, but the surviving complex is an early nineteenth-century prison. It occupies the site of the medieval castle, demolished in 1409.
The new jail opened in 1823. Archibald Elliot's design arranged cell blocks around a central gaoler's house, with enclosed exercise yards between them. The architecture was a statement about order as well as an answer to practical needs.
The castle-like exterior can lead the imagination straight back to Border warfare. Inside, the questions belong to another age. How should prisoners be classified? How much contact should they have? How could a keeper oversee a complex divided into different parts?
A building's style and its purpose need not come from the same century. At Jedburgh, an evocation of a fortress enclosed a contemporary prison plan. Authority borrowed the language of the past while organising a new institution.
The town below gives that statement its setting. Walk uphill and the jail becomes a destination; look downhill and the streets return to the ordinary scale of houses, shops and routes. The separation is physical before a cell door is even reached.
The history of the Borders abbeys offers a different encounter with monumental Jedburgh. Together, abbey and jail show how successive ages gave the town buildings intended to shape behaviour, though through very different kinds of authority.
The prison that reform kept changing
Jedburgh replaced earlier arrangements, including the Newgate jail and a separate bridewell, or house of correction. It belongs to the long effort to make confinement more orderly and purposeful.
Yet reform did not deliver one final design. In 1847 the complex was altered in response to the demands of separation. Arcades were enclosed and shared rooms divided. The surviving building therefore records a debate in stone: spaces that had once made sense were changed to serve a different understanding of discipline.
Separate confinement could be promoted as a way to prevent prisoners corrupting one another and to encourage reflection. Viewed from the cell, however, an architectural principle meant an immediate human experience. A dividing wall controlled conversation, company and the amount of the day spent alone.
That tension matters whenever a prison is called a model. The word tells us that someone intended it to demonstrate an improvement. It does not guarantee that every person confined there experienced it as humane.
Nor should we judge conditions solely from a visitor's walk through an empty historic building. We can leave when we choose. We do not depend on its routines for food, movement, medical attention or contact with family.
Jedburgh is especially valuable because it allows the questions to be asked in the actual spaces. A plan is no longer an abstract diagram. It becomes the width of a door, the position of a window, the distance between a prisoner and the person holding the keys.
Selkirk's jail became a place for books
In Selkirk, the former jail on Ettrick Terrace tells a different afterlife. Built in 1803 to replace the tolbooth as a prison, it was subsequently altered and eventually converted to a library and reading room, presented to the town by Thomas Craig-Brown in 1888.
The change of use is wonderfully suggestive. A building designed to restrict the movement of people became a place for the movement of ideas. Its later architectural treatment added another layer to a structure that had already served the town in a very different way.
Historic Environment Scotland's account preserves an arresting report about the old prison's security. In 1845 it was regarded as poorly secured; the account describes escapes and prisoners leaving in the evening before returning for the jailer's arrival in the morning.
The temptation is to turn that immediately into a merry anecdote about a soft-hearted keeper. The evidence does not give us that explanation. What it does show is a gap between the purpose of the institution and its practical operation.
It is an awkward image to place beside Jedburgh's planned order. The two belong to the same wider history without being interchangeable. Money, staffing, buildings and local habits made a difference.
Selkirk's public life stretches across many centuries, as our story on the lost abbey reminds us. The prison's conversion is another chapter in the repeated remaking of the town, where the old fabric survives by acquiring a new use.
Peebles beneath the familiar street
Not every prison history leaves an imposing building to visit. At Peebles, archaeology has helped recover a civic past hidden beneath later development.
Excavations in the Bridgegate area investigated the site of the medieval tolbooth. The published archaeological study identifies it as an exceptionally important excavated tolbooth site, connecting physical remains with burgh records.
The documents reveal a building whose uses extended beyond custody. Civic government, schooling and provision for poor people all appear in its history. Here again the town's responsibilities pressed into a confined architectural space.
The relationship between location and function is revealing. A tolbooth near an important approach to the town belonged to the practical geography of collecting dues and regulating entry. What seems an odd location to a visitor looking for the modern civic centre may make sense within an older pattern of movement.
Our story on Peebles Castle and the walled town explores that changing layout. The vanished tolbooth is part of the same challenge: learning to see streets as evidence rather than as an unchanging backdrop.
An absence can be instructive. It directs attention to excavation drawings, old maps and the language of council entries. The prisoner has left no scratch we can confidently point to; the building itself may have disappeared. But custody was part of the town's everyday machinery, and the surviving evidence lets it take its place in the picture again.
The prison register opens another door
Buildings tell us how people were intended to be held. Prison registers begin to show who passed through them.
Surviving registers exist for several Borders prisons, including Greenlaw, Jedburgh, Kelso, Peebles and Selkirk. Their coverage varies, and gaps must not be mistaken for years without prisoners. An institution can survive on paper after its rooms have disappeared, just as a building can survive after much of its paperwork has been lost.
A register may record admission and release, age, occupation, birthplace, an offence or the stage of proceedings. Read carefully, the columns can reconnect confinement with the working life outside: a labourer, a servant, a tradesperson, someone whose family waited elsewhere.
The distinction between accusation and conviction is essential. An admission is evidence of custody. It is not automatically proof that the person had been found guilty of the charge mentioned beside their name.
Nor does one line tell the whole story. A legal label compresses a complicated event into the language needed by the institution. To understand more, the researcher may need the trial record, a newspaper account or another document identifying the same person.
There is a peculiar force in finding an ordinary family name in such a record. The past becomes close very quickly. Somebody who had been an entry in a census acquires a period of confinement, and a familiar town acquires a door through which that person once passed.
Who counted as a prisoner?
Our modern mental picture tends towards a convicted offender serving a sentence. Historical custody covered a wider range of circumstances. People could be held while awaiting proceedings; debtors could be confined; the old category of a bridewell carried associations with correction and labour.
Even within Jedburgh's planned complex, the allocation of blocks acknowledged different categories of inmate. The distinctions were built into the arrangement rather than left entirely to daily improvisation.
Those categories shaped the experience, but they did not eliminate individual differences. Two people described under the same heading could have entirely different resources outside. One might expect family help; another might have nobody able to pay a visit or pursue a matter on their behalf.
The question of poverty therefore belongs beside the question of crime. That does not allow us to declare every prisoner an innocent victim. It asks us to pay attention to the circumstances surrounding an offence, a fine or a period of detention.
Our film on being put to the horn explores a different part of Scotland's legal vocabulary. Such terms are useful reminders that past institutions cannot always be translated into a modern category without losing something.
A prison's population was made by the legal powers available to the authorities and by decisions about when to use them. The building contained those decisions; the register preserved their individual consequences.
The people who held the keys
The prisoner and the building are only part of the story. Someone kept the keys, maintained the routines and answered for a failure of security. Someone arranged supplies, dealt with visitors and tried to carry out instructions in the actual circumstances of the place.
Older local arrangements could be uneven. A keeper working within an adapted civic building did not face the same physical possibilities as an officer in a purpose-built complex. Rules on paper were tested against walls, doors, staff and money.
The Selkirk report makes that gap vivid without explaining every cause. Lauder's condemnation shows what happened when an inspector judged local provision against an external expectation. Jedburgh's alterations show the building itself being made to answer a new demand.
There is no need to invent a brutal jailer or a kindly one to understand the human stakes. Whoever held the keys occupied a position of extraordinary practical power over somebody else's day. A door opened for exercise, food or release could matter more than all the impressive architectural language outside.
The work also linked the prison to a community of trades and services. Buildings needed repair; accounts needed settling. Confinement was not sealed off from local life merely because prisoners were sealed inside.
It belonged to the town's economy and administration. The institution that restricted movement depended on a regular movement of other people, goods and information through its gates.
How the small prisons faded
During the nineteenth century, Scottish imprisonment became more closely supervised and more centrally organised. The 1839 legislation established a national framework alongside county responsibility; later changes helped close smaller prisons and shift power further away from individual burghs.
The broad direction is visible in the Borders. Some old premises failed inspection. Some buildings were altered to meet changing standards. Others outlived their function and were sold, converted or allowed to disappear.
At Jedburgh, prison use ended in 1886. The complex eventually became a museum. At Selkirk, the old jail's transformation into a library gave it a durable place in civic life. Different buildings reached different endings.
Centralisation could make arrangements more consistent, but it changed the geography of custody too. A family whose relative was held further away faced a different practical problem from one living close to the local jail. Administrative efficiency and personal proximity were not the same thing.
That is part of what disappears when a small prison closes. The town loses an institution whose work may continue elsewhere, less visibly. People can grow up beside the former building without knowing what happened inside it.
Our film searching for a forgotten jail beneath a bridge catches the fascination of these overlooked places. A modest survival or local tradition can prompt the next question. The answer becomes stronger when the physical clue is followed into records.
Stories that escaped the cell
Prisons attract stories. A daring escape, a cruel punishment, a ghost, an extraordinarily comfortable cell: all offer a memorable way of imagining a place that most people have never experienced as inmates.
Some stories have a firm documentary footing. Others change as they travel. An account of poor security can become a tale of cheerful evenings out. A suggestive opening can become a secret escape route. The temptation grows when the building has already acquired an atmosphere of mystery.
The phrase Jeddart justice, commonly understood as punishment before trial, belongs to the folklore of the region's legal reputation. It is not a substitute for investigating the procedures followed in a particular nineteenth-century case.
Similarly, the harsh history explored in our film on Peebles and the witch trials of 1629 should not be flattened into one timeless prison story. The institutions, offences and beliefs of different periods need their own setting.
There is room for atmosphere without losing those distinctions. A heavy door is evocative because doors really controlled the people behind them. A dark passage can provoke a question without being assigned a prisoner who never walked it.
The best stories do more than make a building sinister. They return a little of the complexity that picturesque walls can hide.
Step outside and listen again
At a historic jail, the most powerful moment may be the one when you leave. The street is there. You choose a direction. You decide whether to linger, find a drink or keep walking. Freedom returns so easily that it can seem unremarkable.
For the people held in these places, that choice was the thing the institution had removed. Its absence links a room beneath a tolbooth, a cell at Jedburgh and the former jail that became Selkirk's library, however different the buildings appear.
The remains deserve attention for their architecture, but also for the questions they leave. Who could order a person into custody? What did the record say, and what did it omit? Who came to ask after them? What happened after release?
The answers will not all survive. Some can be recovered from registers, accounts and court papers. Others remain beyond reach, with only the building to suggest the scale of a confined day.
Return to that imagined sound at the beginning: the cart, the voices, the bell. Ordinary town life passing close by. These were not distant places outside the Borders' story. They were rooms within it, separated from the familiar streets by a lock and the decision of somebody holding a key.

Your memories and comments
Do you remember this place, or have something to add? Share a memory, ask a question or help us fill in the story.
Loading comments…