CRIME AND PUNISHMENT

The Last Public Executions in the Scottish Borders

From Hawick’s green to Jedburgh Castle Jail and Greenlaw, follow the final era of public executions and the human lives behind the Borders’ scaffolds.

Genscu 3 Nov 2026 Across the Scottish Borders
Estimated reading time · 17 min

Imagine the walk up Castlegate in Jedburgh before the shops have quite woken. The street climbs towards battlements, the sky broadens, and a building resembling a small fortress takes command of the town. It is an imposing approach even now. In the nineteenth century, a condemned prisoner could look towards that same world knowing he would never walk freely through it again.

The Borders’ public executions belong to recognisable places: a green in Hawick, a road between Earlston and Greenlaw, the prison at Jedburgh and Greenlaw itself. They were not all medieval events in a safely distant age. Some happened while railways were spreading across Scotland and the towns were acquiring the outlines of modern life.

Nor did the practice end everywhere at once. Hawick’s documented hanging of 1814, Jedburgh’s execution of Thomas Wilson in 1849 and John Williams’s death at Greenlaw in 1853 form different stages in a retreat from public punishment. Scotland’s last public execution came elsewhere, at Dumfries in 1868.

Following those stages means looking beyond the scaffold. There were victims whose names deserve to survive, families facing disgrace and bereavement, officials carrying out sentences, printers selling the story and crowds whose presence was part of the punishment’s purpose. The unsettling thing is how ordinary the surrounding landscape remains.

When Punishment Needed an Audience

A public execution was meant to be seen. The authorities did not simply deprive the condemned person of life; they made the act a statement to everyone permitted to watch. The place, procession and preparations helped turn a judicial sentence into an event in the life of a community.

That was particularly powerful in a small town or rural district. A hanging could be an exceptional occurrence rather than a familiar spectacle. People might travel towards it, interrupt their work or encounter the preparations on roads they normally used for markets and visits. Punishment entered a shared landscape.

The crowd was more than a background detail. Without spectators, an exemplary punishment lost much of its intended force. Yet the authorities could not entirely control what those spectators made of it. Some might accept the warning. Others might feel sympathy, revulsion, curiosity or a mixture that changed as the event unfolded.

We should resist assigning one emotion to an entire crowd. Silence would not necessarily signify approval, nor attendance a wish to see someone suffer. What can be said is that the state deliberately placed death before the public and expected it to teach a lesson.

That expectation belongs within the older world explored in our film on being put to the horn. Proclamation, reputation and the visible reach of authority mattered in a region where law had long been contested.

The Long Shadow of Jeddart Justice

The phrase Jeddart justice has outlived the conditions that produced it. Usually understood as hanging a man first and trying him afterwards, it gives Jedburgh a ferocious place in popular memory. It is also a proverb with several competing explanations, rather than a reliable description of every trial held in the town.

Accounts have connected it with different episodes of harsh Border government. The underlying association is clear enough: punishment so swift or sweeping that justice appeared to follow force. Pinning the expression to one colourful incident is much less secure.

This matters when we approach the nineteenth century. A man tried at Jedburgh’s Circuit Court was not simply caught in an unchanged medieval custom. Indictments, witnesses, verdicts, petitions and decisions about mercy formed part of an established judicial process. That process could be severe, fallible and unequal without being identical to the proverb.

The older reputation nevertheless lingered around the place. Jedburgh stood at a meeting point between royal power and the difficult frontier. Our account of the shaping of the Anglo-Scots Border follows the longer struggle over who could command this country.

By the time the last public hangings were taking place, the central question had changed. The state no longer had to prove that a separate Border society could be brought within its reach. It had to explain why killing a prisoner before an audience remained an appropriate expression of that reach.

A Castle Built for Confinement

Jedburgh Castle Jail looks older than it is. The medieval castle had been demolished in 1409. The castellated prison now occupying its mound dates to 1823, designed by Archibald Elliott, with substantial changes in 1847. Its towers and battlements gave a nineteenth-century institution the appearance of an ancestral stronghold.

The site already carried the memory of punishment: the mound had been used for the town gallows. Building a prison there joined a new scheme of confinement to an existing landscape of authority. The street still led uphill towards the place where the town’s power over prisoners became most visible.

Inside, the arrangement was carefully organised. Cell blocks stood around the gaoler’s house, with enclosed exercise spaces between them. Different categories of prisoner were separated. The architecture expressed an intention to classify and manage people, rather than merely lock everyone behind a strong door.

A prison could be designed as an improvement on earlier accommodation and still impose profound isolation. The changes of 1847 made the separation of prisoners more rigorous, altering shared spaces and the way confinement was experienced.

Today the building gives physical shape to that history. Its stone cells and controlled routes allow us to understand something that a list of executions cannot convey: the final sentence began to shape a prisoner’s world long before he reached the scaffold. Waiting, knowing and uncertainty were part of the punishment too.

Hawick, 12 May 1814

The documented Hawick case takes us away from the familiar castle silhouette. John Gibson was tried at Jedburgh and executed at Hawick on 12 May 1814 for murdering his wife. The gallows was erected on a green opposite the house where he had stabbed her.

That location was deliberate. A punishment carried out near the crime made a direct connection between the violence and its judicial consequence. For neighbours, the place was already part of daily life. Afterwards it could carry the memory of two deaths, the murder and the execution.

The victim must not disappear behind the man whose execution generated the spectacle. The brief accounts used here identify her as Gibson’s wife rather than giving a securely established name. That limitation is sobering: the condemned man is readily named, while the woman whose life he took is harder to recover from these summaries.

Contemporary reporting described a very large gathering and treated the execution as an exceptional event for Hawick. There is no need to repeat a guessed attendance figure or invent a collective reaction. The unusual decision to bring the sentence to the town already tells us how strongly the authorities wanted the locality involved.

Hawick is more often remembered through the working life of its mills, including Peter Scott’s knitwear business. This earlier story exposes another history written into its streets, one that industrial achievement did not erase.

The Sentence Came to the Scene

Gibson’s execution belonged to a practice historians call crime-scene execution. In early nineteenth-century Scotland, some offenders were sent from the place of trial to the district where the offence had occurred, so punishment could be displayed in direct relation to it.

The distinction is easy to miss. A trial at Jedburgh does not automatically mean a hanging at Jedburgh. Courts served wide districts; a sentence might specify a different location. The administrative map and the map of the final journey were not always the same.

For the authorities, selecting the scene could make a case exemplary. It brought the condemned person back into the community affected by the crime and transformed a familiar site into a warning. For local inhabitants, the same choice imposed a spectacle on the place where they lived.

Imagine the practical disruption: timber and equipment arriving, an area being prepared, people approaching along ordinary roads. These are the arrangements a public hanging required, rather than a surviving eyewitness picture of a particular morning. The machinery of punishment could not appear without labour, movement and decisions about space.

The Borders’ road network was essential to that process. Routes carried officers, prisoners, news and spectators as well as livestock and trade. The landscape of the lost roads before the A7 and A68 can look different when we remember the journeys it once contained.

Robert Scott and the Road to Greenlaw

On 29 October 1823, Robert Scott was executed on the road between Earlston and Greenlaw, near the place where he had murdered James Aitcheson and Robert Simm. Both victims were associated with Greenlaw. The case had been tried at the Jedburgh Circuit Court in September.

A surviving printed account described Scott being taken from Jedburgh towards the place of execution and handed from the custody of the Roxburghshire sheriff to that of Berwickshire. Even allowing for the broadside’s appetite for drama, the passage between jurisdictions is a striking detail. The final journey made government visible across the countryside.

The men had been returning from Earlston fair when the fatal violence occurred. A road associated with a public gathering and ordinary travel became the place of their deaths. The authorities then chose to place Scott’s execution close to that same point.

His body was afterwards sent to Edinburgh for dissection. Punishment extended beyond the hanging itself. The condemned person did not necessarily receive the ordinary burial that families might otherwise have expected.

There is a temptation to turn this into an excursion to an exact roadside spot. The contemporary language and later descriptions do not justify that confidence here. What can be followed is the larger geography: Earlston, the road towards Greenlaw, a trial at Jedburgh and the organised return to the district of the crime. The names of Aitcheson and Simm belong at its centre.

A Penny for the Story

Robert Scott’s execution survives partly because somebody sold it. The broadside was a commercial object, designed to catch attention and turn a shocking event into printed news. Its headline promised details of the execution and the condemned man’s final behaviour.

Such sheets sit at an uncomfortable meeting point between evidence and entertainment. They can preserve dates, names and arrangements that would otherwise be difficult to find. They also shape the event into a recognisable moral drama, full of certainty about guilt, repentance and the lesson the reader ought to learn.

The language of a broadside was not the neutral voice of a camera. Publishers needed customers, and printers could benefit from precisely the appetite for spectacle that public punishment encouraged. The crowd around the scaffold had a counterpart in the readership beyond it.

This was one reason executions could have an afterlife far outside the town where they occurred. A printed sheet travelled. It could be read aloud, passed between households or kept long after the immediate news had faded. A frightening local incident became part of a wider culture of crime stories.

Our history of the Borders’ post and Royal Mail describes other ways information moved through the region. News of punishment travelled along those same human networks, even when the printed story arrived by different hands. The public execution did not finish when its audience dispersed. A reader could meet the case at a distance, with no knowledge of the street, the victim or the prisoner beyond what the printer supplied. That made the choice of language especially powerful. The same event could become a warning about crime, an account of repentance or an unsettling entertainment, depending on how its story was framed.

St Boswells Fair and a Young Man’s Death

The 1849 case began in a setting far more crowded than the roadside where Scott’s victims were killed. Disorder at St Boswells fair ended in the death of William Lauder, a young man who had been helping the police during an attempt to control the disturbance.

Thomas Wilson, John Brady and Peter Rafferty were among those brought before the court at Jedburgh. A contemporary newspaper account described numerous witnesses and a case turning on participation in the assault. Wilson and Brady were sentenced to death; Brady subsequently received a reprieve.

The fair is an important part of the setting. Large gatherings brought people into close contact who might otherwise be separated by work, residence and social standing. Trade, drink, policing and the pressure of a crowd could become entangled. None of those circumstances excuses the killing or allows us to reconstruct every person’s actions from a short report.

What it does reveal is the human difficulty within a capital prosecution involving several defendants. Responsibility had to be assigned to individuals within a confused public event. The decision that one man would live while another would die gave the case a particularly stark ending.

Lauder’s death should remain visible throughout that ending. A history concerned only with whether Wilson was guilty, reprieved or hanged risks making the person who first lost his life merely the opening sentence of somebody else’s story.

The Possibility of Mercy

A death sentence did not always lead to execution. Brady’s reprieve demonstrates how the story could change after the court pronounced its verdict. Between sentence and scaffold there remained a possibility that somebody in authority would intervene.

For anyone waiting under such a sentence, that possibility must have altered the meaning of time. A day passing could bring the execution nearer, but it could also leave room for a decision that would preserve life. We cannot know the private thoughts of Wilson or Brady. The structure of their predicament is enough to make the waiting intelligible.

Mercy also introduced a further layer of responsibility. A court could establish a sentence under the law, while a later decision determined whether the ultimate punishment would actually be carried out. The difference between defendants was therefore not always exhausted by the words guilty or not guilty.

The surviving petition catalogue places Wilson and Brady together. On paper they remain linked by the same prosecution. Their endings diverged. That divergence is one of the most difficult things to contemplate when following a capital case: two names can occupy the same document while the future is opening for one and closing for the other.

A reprieve should not be confused with a declaration of innocence. It means that the condemned person was spared execution. Nor does the refusal of mercy make every uncertainty vanish. Those distinctions mattered most to the people who had the least power to control them, the prisoners and the families waiting beyond the walls.

Jedburgh’s Hanging of 1849

Thomas Wilson was hanged at Jedburgh on 25 October 1849. He is commonly remembered as the last man executed there. His case sits close enough to the prison’s surviving fabric that the history can feel more immediate than much older tales attached to the town.

There is an awkward detail in the later record: some execution compilations call him John Wilson. Contemporary reporting of the trial and a surviving Home Office petition catalogue identify Thomas Wilson alongside John Brady. It is Thomas who belongs in this account.

More dramatic claims have gathered around him, including the assertion that his innocence was proved after his death. The evidence does not establish such an exoneration. It would be wrong to convert a powerful local tradition into a judicial finding.

The emotional force does not depend on doing so. One defendant received mercy; another went to the scaffold. A young victim was dead. Families on more than one side had to live with the consequences. The fact that the punishment was irreversible made every decision leading to it exceptionally consequential.

The jail has acquired ghost stories, as old prisons often do. Those stories reveal the hold the building retains on the imagination. Wilson’s documented history is already troubling enough, without requiring an apparition to tell us that a public execution leaves a long shadow. We can feel the weight of that history while keeping the supernatural stories in their own place.

Greenlaw, 14 March 1853

Four years after Wilson’s death, another execution took place in Berwickshire. John Williams was hanged at Greenlaw on 14 March 1853 for the murder of Andrew Mather at Cleekhimin Toll Bar. The National Records of Scotland catalogue records his trial at the High Court in Edinburgh on 21 February and the death sentence that followed.

This is a useful corrective to a story centred entirely on Jedburgh. Greenlaw had its own place in county administration and punishment. The region’s final nineteenth-century executions did not form a single sequence outside one prison door.

A toll bar was part of the infrastructure of movement. People passed through, payments were collected, and the road brought strangers into contact with a person whose work depended on staying in one place. Mather’s occupation as a tollkeeper places his death within that everyday geography.

Williams’s execution is among the latest public hangings documented in the Borders material examined for this account. That is narrower than treating every local list as a complete register for the whole modern council area, but it gives the case its proper place near the end of the story.

Greenlaw also makes the date of 1868 easier to understand. A national legal change can come years after a locality has last witnessed the practice it ends. For people in a particular Borders town, the final scaffold might already have become a memory before public executions formally ceased across Britain.

The Last Scottish Crowd Was Elsewhere

Scotland’s last public execution took place at Dumfries on 12 May 1868. Robert Smith was hanged for the murder of Thomasina Scott. Dumfries belongs to a neighbouring region, not the Scottish Borders, and its national distinction should not be transferred to Jedburgh or Greenlaw.

Later that month, the Capital Punishment Amendment Act ended public executions for murder. The death penalty continued behind prison walls. What disappeared was the sanctioned public gathering around the act itself.

That distinction changes how the ending should be told. Britain did not decide in 1868 that no prisoner should ever be executed. It decided executions should no longer be staged for the public in the same way. The state retained the punishment while changing who could witness it.

To someone opposed to public spectacles, that might appear a civilising reform. To someone concerned about scrutiny, concealment raised a different question. Removing the crowd also removed the possibility of ordinary people seeing directly what was being done in their name.

The change closed one chapter while leaving a much longer argument unfinished. The Borders’ last public hangings belong to the period before that threshold, when justice was still expected to prove its force in an open space. Their absence after 1868 did not mean the machinery of capital punishment had stopped. The prison wall now separated most of the public from the final act.

Families Outside the Picture

Most public accounts follow the condemned person from conviction to execution, then stop. Families had no equivalent ending. The relatives of victims lived with bereavement; those connected to the condemned faced loss, shame, practical hardship or anger that no formal sentence could resolve.

We cannot recover those experiences simply by imagining them. There is no warrant to supply a mother’s words, a child at a window or a widow’s private response where the record does not preserve them. But acknowledging the families changes the scale of the story. A hanging was not a self-contained event affecting one man.

The same is true of the people whose work made it possible. Warders, sheriffs, clergy and the executioner occupied different positions, with different responsibilities. Their presence does not tell us how they felt. It does show that the spectacle depended on an institution and a chain of decisions, rather than a single figure operating a scaffold.

Victims’ names offer a necessary point of return: James Aitcheson, Robert Simm, William Lauder and Andrew Mather. Gibson’s wife, whose name is harder to recover here, deserves the same recognition.

The most humane way to revisit this history is to hold both kinds of loss in view. The murder and execution were connected, but they were separate acts, each leaving people behind. For a family, the date printed at the end of the story was the beginning of another life, organised around someone’s absence.

Walking Back Down Castlegate

At Jedburgh, the battlements remain above the street. The building’s survival allows the nineteenth century to press close: stone, iron, narrow spaces and the controlled movement between them. Visitors arrive with the freedom to leave, a freedom that makes the cells easier to enter and much harder to understand fully.

The town beyond is larger than its prison history. Abbey ruins, working streets and generations of ordinary life surround the mound. A place should not be reduced to its worst moments, any more than a person should be reduced to the final entry beside a name.

Yet remembering is different from reducing. Hawick’s green, the Earlston road, Jedburgh’s jail and Greenlaw recover a history that could otherwise dissolve into vague tales about hanging trees. They show where particular decisions became irreversible.

Our films about witch execution sites and the small prison beneath a bridge explore other forms of punishment and confinement. Each belongs to its own period and circumstances. Together they remind us how closely the history of justice lies beside familiar routes.

Walk back down Castlegate and the view narrows into the town again. That ordinary movement is the final contrast the place offers. We can turn away, cross the street and continue our day. The people whose names survive in these cases could not all do the same.

Your memories and comments

Do you remember this place, or have something to add? Share a memory, ask a question or help us fill in the story.

Loading comments…

No advertising or abusive comments. Links are reviewed and remain plain text. See our privacy policy.

History. Experiences. Creativity.

Discover
Scottish Borders

Four websites. Four ways to explore.

Read the stories and watch the films. Join Mark on a guided tour. Follow an audio walk at your own pace. Discover his wildlife and nature-inspired art.

One independent project, bringing the Borderlands to life.

Explore the four websites