GUARDING THE DEAD

Body Snatchers and Borders Graveyards

A little watchtower at Eckford reveals the fear of body snatchers, the families who guarded their dead, and the uneasy price of Scotland’s medical progress.

Genscu 2 Nov 2026 Across the Scottish Borders
Estimated reading time · 14 min

Imagine the last mourner leaving a Borders kirkyard on a short winter afternoon. The earth is still raw. A spade has made a dark scar in the grass, and the family has gone home to a house that will never sound quite the same again.

But someone else is coming to the grave.

He may be a neighbour with a lantern, taking his turn at the watch. He may be a relative who cannot bear to leave. For a few hours, while the parish sleeps, his task is to make sure that the person buried that afternoon remains there until morning.

That is an imagined scene, but the fear behind it was real. At Eckford, between Kelso and Jedburgh, a small round watchtower survives in the churchyard. It was built against a threat that seems almost impossible now: men who dug up the recently dead and sold their bodies to the people teaching medicine.

The tower is a remarkable place to begin. For all the sensational stories that have grown around Scotland’s body snatchers, the deepest part of this history belongs to ordinary families. A burial was supposed to be the final act of care. Instead, it could become the beginning of another anxious vigil.

The little tower that changes the view

A churchyard can encourage us to look backwards in centuries. Here is an old inscription, there a weathered skull, beyond it a wall rebuilt when someone’s grandfather was a boy. The watchtower at Eckford asks us to look at a different sort of evidence: a building put up because people expected trouble after dark.

Historic Environment Scotland’s listing identifies an early nineteenth-century watch-house among the features of Eckford Church and graveyard. The parish’s own history describes the little round structure as the local ‘ghoul’ tower, erected as a precaution against body snatchers. Its survival gives the subject a physical weight that a lurid tale alone cannot provide.

The name invites the imagination to run. Yet this was practical architecture. It offered a position from which to keep watch, and somewhere for a watcher to be rather than standing exposed between the stones throughout the night. Fear had become a small building of stone.

Mark’s film about Eckford Church, body snatchers and the jougs explores the unsettling company these relics keep. The jougs belong to an older world of public discipline. The watch-house belongs to a struggle over the dead. Both make a quiet rural kirk a more complicated place than it first appears.

Why anyone wanted a body

It is tempting to begin and end with the men carrying sacks over churchyard walls. But they had customers. Without the demand from anatomy teaching, there was no reason to steal a corpse.

A doctor needed to understand the body beneath the skin. A surgeon treating a wound or deciding where to make an incision required more than confidence. Studying actual human anatomy supplied knowledge that diagrams, animal dissection and lectures could not fully replace. Medical education therefore created a serious practical need, while the legal supply of bodies remained sharply restricted.

The University of Glasgow records that, across the eighty years from 1752 to 1832, it received only twenty-three bodies from the lawful source of executed murderers. Its history also describes the separate anatomy schools which had no such legitimate supply. Those figures belong to Glasgow, not the Borders, but they expose the problem facing Scottish medical education.

A rural family did not have to live beside an anatomy theatre to be affected. Demand was concentrated in teaching centres; the fear spread through the country surrounding them. Roads that carried produce, passengers and messages could carry other things as well. The distance between a peaceful burial ground and a city buyer was not necessarily a protection.

That does not prove that every Borders churchyard was raided. It explains why people here could reasonably feel vulnerable, and why a watch-house at Eckford makes sense within a much larger Scottish story.

Two kinds of resurrection

The name ‘resurrection men’ carried an ugly irony. In Christian language, resurrection promised life beyond death. In the anatomy trade, it meant raising a body from the ground for sale.

For a bereaved family, the offence was personal before it was philosophical. The hands laid out in the coffin had been someone’s mother’s hands. The face under the cloth had smiled across a table. Whatever a lecturer might call a useful specimen, the family knew a person.

Religion gave burial further meaning, but we should not reduce every objection to a single doctrine about what would happen on the Last Day. Respect, affection, decency and the right to mourn were powerful reasons in themselves. An emptied grave was an assault on the living as well as the dead.

There was also a terrible mismatch of language. The anatomy school spoke of subjects and supply. The household spoke of a father, a sister, a child. Each language could be used sincerely; one could also be used to avoid hearing the other.

This is why the story cannot be told simply as enlightened science battling ignorant villagers. Anatomical knowledge mattered. So did the people whose bodies supplied it. The question was not whether medicine should learn, but who had the power to decide what learning could take from someone else.

The grave was only safe after time had passed

The greatest danger came soon after burial, while a body was still useful to an anatomist. Protection did not always have to last for ever. It had to frustrate the trade during that vulnerable interval.

That fact produced a grim kind of engineering. Heavy stones could obstruct a grave. Iron devices could enclose or cover the coffin. Some could be removed after decomposition had made the remains less attractive to a buyer, then used again for another burial.

A mortsafe was therefore different from a decorative railing round a family plot. It was a defence designed for a particular threat. Across Scotland, surviving examples range in construction and appearance; there was no single standard object placed in every churchyard. Large permanent cages, reusable coffin-shaped iron covers, mort-stones, watch-houses and secure temporary vaults should not all be treated as interchangeable names for the same thing.

National Museums Scotland describes families using locked mortsafes during the first weeks after burial, while those unable to afford such protection might keep vigil. The logic was painfully straightforward. If a community could not make the thieves disappear, it could try to make theft too difficult, too noisy or too dangerous to attempt.

At Eckford, the evidence we can point to is the watch-house. We do not need to surround it with an invented collection of local iron cages to make its story compelling.

A neighbour’s turn in the darkness

Now picture the imagined watcher again. He has work in the morning. The night is long, and the smallest sound acquires importance when he is trying to decide whether it comes from a branch, an animal or a man.

From the road in daylight, a kirkyard seems open and readable. In darkness, familiar distances collapse. A pale stone becomes a shape; the spaces between graves become pockets of uncertainty. Keeping watch would demand attention even when nothing happened. Especially when nothing happened.

That effort reveals something about community. A family in mourning could not remain awake indefinitely. Protection might depend on people taking turns, on someone accepting inconvenience for a neighbour, and on the belief that another household would do the same when needed. The graveyard was a shared place, and its vulnerability could become a shared problem.

We cannot supply Eckford with an exact rota, a nightly wage or a named watcher without the records to support them. But we can recognise what a watch-house required: people willing to occupy it. The little building was not a defence by itself.

The most moving part of the story may be this unrecorded labour of care. History remembers the thief because theft makes a story. It is much less likely to preserve the name of the person who sat through a freezing night and ensured that there was no story to tell in the morning.

The Borders tale that gives the thieves a fright

Eckford also has a story in which the feared men become the frightened ones. In the parish tradition, James Goodfellow, a Kelso man returning from courting, discovers body snatchers at work. He distracts them by sending their pony away, then takes the dead person’s place. When the thieves discover that their supposed cargo is warm and very much alive, they flee. Goodfellow ends up with the horse and cart.

It is a splendid piece of local storytelling, shaped around a reversal everyone can enjoy. The people who treat a human body as a parcel are defeated when the parcel answers back.

We should enjoy it as a parish tale, rather than dress it in the authority of a recovered court judgment. Its telling does not give us a secure date, a prosecution or a receipt for the cart. The tower is tangible evidence of precaution; the Goodfellow episode belongs to the tradition that grew around the fear.

That distinction need not drain the life from the story. Folklore often gives a community the victory that ordinary circumstances denied it. Here, cunning defeats predation, a local man takes control, and the threat runs off into the dark. At the end, the bereaved have their dead and the village has the last laugh.

Burke and Hare were murderers

Two names overshadow almost every discussion of Scottish body snatching: William Burke and William Hare. Their crimes made the fear of the anatomy trade unforgettable, but it matters that they were not merely grave robbers.

They killed people and sold their bodies to the Edinburgh anatomy teacher Robert Knox. The University of Edinburgh’s account places their murders in 1827–28 and records that Burke was hanged on 28 January 1829 after Hare gave evidence against him. Burke’s own body was then dissected.

The distinction changes the story. A resurrectionist stole a body after death. Burke and Hare created their supply by bringing death about. The money attached to a corpse had made a living person vulnerable.

Nor should Knox be casually described as a convicted murderer. The Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh’s biographical record is explicit that he was never formally accused or convicted of a crime. That does not settle the moral questions surrounding the purchase of bodies; it stops us claiming a legal outcome that did not occur.

Famous names attract travelling stories. Once Burke and Hare had become shorthand for the whole business, it was easy for later local accounts to attach them to every suspicious cart or strange visitor. A tale placing them on a Borders road needs evidence of its own. Their notoriety cannot supply the missing proof.

Remember the people behind the names

The National Library of Scotland’s collections preserve the enormous public appetite for accounts of the West Port murders: reports, pictures, ballads and other printed material. The scandal was frightening, but it was also something people bought and consumed.

Among the victims recalled in that material are Mary Paterson, James Wilson and Margaret Docherty. Those names matter. Repeating only the killers’ names leaves the people they killed in the shadows, reduced once again to what someone else did with their bodies.

The same imbalance threatens a story about a churchyard. An ingenious theft, a mysterious coffin or a comic escape can eclipse the family who had buried someone. The danger becomes entertainment, while the grief which gave it meaning disappears.

A more revealing way to look at the watchtower is to stand mentally on the other side of the funeral. What would it mean to walk away unsure that you had done enough? What would it mean to hear a rumour the next morning and feel obliged to return? Those questions do not require lurid description. They make the past human through something most of us can understand: the wish that a person we love should be treated with care.

A solution that carried another injustice

Parliament eventually acted. The Anatomy Act of 1832 expanded lawful access to bodies for anatomical examination and placed the teaching of anatomy within a licensing and inspection framework. It helped remove the shortage on which the resurrectionists’ business depended.

Yet this was not an uncomplicated happy ending. As Parliament’s own historical account explains, unclaimed bodies from institutions such as hospitals, prisons and workhouses became available. For people living close to destitution, the fear could move from the churchyard to the institution.

The story of the Borders poorhouses helps explain why that mattered. Poverty was already capable of stripping people of privacy, independence and control over everyday decisions. A system drawing anatomical material disproportionately from those without money or someone able to claim them raised a further question: whose death was most likely to become a resource?

It is possible to recognise the Act’s effect on grave robbing and still see its inequality. A family with money and influence stood in a different position from someone dying without an effective advocate. The disappearance of a clandestine market did not automatically create equal power for everyone touched by its replacement.

The new arrangement made one form of violation harder. It also left a long argument about consent, dignity and who gets to speak for the dead.

The argument was heard at the time

We do not have to impose all these concerns from the present. In the Commons debate on the Anatomy Bill on 11 April 1832, members argued about the position of poorer people, safeguards and the danger of allowing control over a body to rest with whoever happened to possess it.

Supporters argued that better anatomical education would benefit the poor as patients, and that increasing lawful supply would reduce the rewards for terrible crimes. Critics questioned whether the proposed protections were adequate and whether those most affected would have the means to challenge wrongdoing. The competing claims were already in the room.

Read in that light, a watch-house is part of a debate larger than local crime. It belongs to a period when medical knowledge was expanding faster than agreement about how it should be obtained. The object in the kirkyard and the argument in Parliament were answers to the same conflict, approached from opposite ends.

One began with the needs of a profession. The other began beside a newly filled grave. A humane solution had to be answerable to both.

What a quiet graveyard can tell us

There is a difference between discovering evidence and recognising a mood. A remote setting, a high wall or a sinister-looking outbuilding may feel right for a resurrectionist story. Feeling right is not enough to identify a mort-house or prove that a particular burial was disturbed.

A building might have served as a store, a burial aisle or a later shelter. An iron enclosure might protect a family lair without being a reusable mortsafe. The name used locally may preserve something valuable, but a dated description, a plan or an account can change the interpretation.

That is part of the pleasure of looking carefully. The Borders is full of buildings that become more interesting when we stop forcing them into a single familiar story. Mark’s film on lost and ruined churches around Jedburgh and Roxburghshire opens another way into that landscape, where worship, family memory, abandonment and rebuilding overlap.

The same care applies to gravestones. Their symbols and lettering deserve to be read before they are turned into props for a ghost story. The dead had lives before they acquired an atmosphere.

Following the evidence home

If a family remembers a story about watching a grave, its value does not depend on immediately proving a dramatic crime. The memory may preserve a practice, an anxiety or the name of a vanished building. It is a starting point from which to ask better questions.

When was the account first written down? Was its speaker remembering an event or repeating something heard from an older relative? Does a newspaper name the parish, or simply repeat a rumour from somewhere else? Do two apparently separate books turn out to have borrowed the same anecdote? These are the small tests that turn a good tale into a stronger piece of local history.

A watch-house and a remembered warning may tell different parts of the truth. One proves that a community invested in protection. The other shows how that investment was explained and remembered. Neither needs to be inflated into a nightly procession of thieves.

For visitors, the best approach is also the simplest: look at the building in its setting. Notice its relationship to the graves, the church and the approaches. Then think about the people whose knowledge of those same distances was acquired in darkness, when they were trying to keep someone else safe.

Rest was something people had to defend

The Borders has no shortage of fortifications. Towers, castle sites and defensive houses make it easy to tell a history of danger through the buildings people left behind. Eckford offers a smaller, later defence, built for those who could no longer defend themselves.

Its scale is part of its power. This was not a stronghold commanding a valley. It was a little place in a churchyard, concerned with the distance between a door and a grave, between hearing a sound and deciding to raise an alarm.

Imagine morning returning. The stones recover their ordinary shapes. A watcher stretches stiff legs, and someone else comes along the path. The fresh earth has not been disturbed. Nothing has happened.

For the family who buried a person there, that uneventful morning was the whole point.

The body-snatching era is often remembered for the audacity of the men who broke into graves. The watchtower asks us to remember another sort of determination: neighbours who would not readily surrender their dead, and communities insisting that a person did not cease to deserve care when the funeral ended.

Your memories and comments

Do you remember this place, or have something to add? Share a memory, ask a question or help us fill in the story.

Loading comments…

No advertising or abusive comments. Links are reviewed and remain plain text. See our privacy policy.

History. Experiences. Creativity.

Discover
Scottish Borders

Four websites. Four ways to explore.

Read the stories and watch the films. Join Mark on a guided tour. Follow an audio walk at your own pace. Discover his wildlife and nature-inspired art.

One independent project, bringing the Borderlands to life.

Explore the four websites